Propellerhead Software
Old 2002-08-09, 00:19
Posts: n/a
Ive Made My Choice

thanz to all who repplied to an earlier thread on Cubase vs Logic

I'm goin with Logic as Im a mac user and can only hope for the best from the two teamed up....

In 5 buisness days hopefully ill have something to talk about as a reason user
Old 2002-08-09, 03:12
mikeweeks mikeweeks is offline
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 0
Re: Ive Made My Choice

Right on!

did you go for the big box? Its a mess o stuff - let me know what you think, as I'm jsut starting out with Logic too.

Old 2002-08-09, 06:52
Posts: n/a
Re: Ive Made My Choice

Went for LAP 5 and less than three hours after I ordered got an email from tech support and it still only has ReWire 1 support so I ditched the order and am going to wait for Cubase SX on Mac.

sux cause ive been using micrologic so im use to the interface but im upgrading so i can get things like Reason

Emagic looses this time and i have a feeling with as popular as reason is they will loose more and more until the completely implament RW2 into their system
Old 2002-08-09, 19:19
lucille lucille is offline
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 98
Re: thoughts on Logic

I have serious reservations re Emagic LAP.
None of this means that it is not a great
DAW--perhaps the best-- only that you should take the following into consideration:

First--the Rewire 1 implementation has
ranged from iffy to non-existent in recent
relaeases. Although they will eventually get
Rewire2 off the ground--the Rewire track record is
not encouraging. If you look at vsti integraion--
you'll see many similar problems.

Reason users are not really in Logic's core
demagraphic--i see Emagic as much more
concerned with Pro Tools issues.

Second--Read the Sonik matter forum on the web--
there are many many problems in 5.x land--and
some of thm have gotten worse in 5.2. Be prepared
for funkiness

Third: the strengths of Logic don't play to the
new soft synth driven DAW. The somewhat
overhyped "environment" is really only
applicable to midi out integration--its interesting
if obtuse technology--but its not really helpful
to Reason/Softsynth users.

You can take shots at sx and sonar as well--
good luck.
Old 2002-08-10, 03:20
wrwellen wrwellen is offline
Join Date: Dec 2001
Posts: 0
Re: thoughts on Logic

:Lucille - Thanks for your always informative posts at the p-head and sonik forums.

Like a lot of other folks, I really like both logic and reason. I'm comfortable in both apps. I would like very much to see emagic properly implement rewire 2 so I can use reason as essentially a soft synth in logic. At present, I will work up songs in reason, save tracks as wav files and dump them into logic. Then I record vocals, guitar, etc. I also do a lot of parts on the ESX24 which is a great sampler. Obviously, there are limitations to working this way.

I don't use much midi, so I don't really care how great the logic environment is. However, I love the way logic sounds. (The reason tracks sound much much better after I get them into logic, but that's another topic.) I love the effects in logic. It is truly amazing in a lot of different ways.

I use a pc. Before the July 1 acquisition of Emagic by Apple, I was content to patiently wait for Emagic to finally get their act together with rewire 2. Now it appears that 5.2 may be the last update for pc and of course, it doesn't have rewire 2. I don't know that we will ever see a version of logic for pc that has non-buggy implementation of rewire 2. That truly sucks.

So now I have to decide between pc and mac. If I stay pc, I need to upgrade. At present, you get much more bang for your buck with a pc. By migrating some of the stuff I have in my current set up, I will end up with a killer pc system for at least half the price of a comparable mac.

Lucille, I gather you stayed pc and dumped logic for sonar. How is that working out for you? Did you try Cubase sx? People are posting that sonar's rewire 2 implementation is better than cubase's, although sonar is limited to 16 rewire channels. If I stay pc, I am thinking I could work up tracks in sonar rewired with reason and then dump them into logic to clean up, maybe add some more tracks and mix. Did you try this? How does sonar sound compared to logic? Does using wdm make a difference?

Of course, if I spend the bucks to go mac, I may ultimately end up with logic and reason rewired together perfectly and who knows what other goodies Emapple will have in store for mac users.

Graymadder - I feel your pain. Good luck with cubase and report back.
Old 2002-08-10, 04:45
lucille lucille is offline
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 98
Re: decisions, decisions...

:::Hello W.

I switched to Sonar instead of going LAP 5.x
when I concluded Emagic was not serious
about supporting rewire. I did not however,
anticipate them dropping the PC.

Here's my take. Sonar has the best midi tools
of the big 3. The drum map functionality in
Sonar is amazing; it effectively allows you to
use Redrum as a Battery style 40 or 50 cell
drum machine sampler. (It also allows Redrum
to be GM compliant--a plus if you trade
files) The rewire implementation is solid,
but allows oly 15 midi sends. Since I do
mostly pop and dance, this is not really a limitation.
I also end up programming a lot of stuff in
Reason. I program all my automation natively
in Reason. Sonar also has excellent loop/slicing
support. Rewire is certain to come up to 32
or 64 in the next realease.

I am less familiar with SX, but I think it has some
form of drum mapping as well; I believe the
Rewire midi send limit in Sx is 32 or 64, a major
plus. I loved the Musikmesse Sx demo that
was on the web, but an in person demo turned
me off--there just seemed to be alot to classic
Cubase wierdness still in the program. i also
found the graphics busy--but many call Sonar
a "spreadsheet".

Soundwise--Its so hard to say. Logic is certainly
the loudest of the 3. Some people mistake its
higher base gain for sound density. I think you
just have to get some demos and play some
.wavs. The fx in Sonar are surprisingly good; some
people write that it sounds thin. I don't know.

Bottom line: If you really like Reason, I would not
move to the mac to follow logic. Emagic doen't seem
very interested in rewire. If your willing to spend, Sx
is probrobly the better PC choice. I like the Sonar
interface and the midi tools--so I went that way.

If you really like Logic, a lot of the functionality
of Reason is availible in Kontact, esx24 and
Battery. Logic seems to be trying to pave a
higher end profile with its new proprietary
instruments ($$$).

I just can't escape the Reason magnet--I'm just
more--far more--creative in that program than
any other.

Oh yeah, PC's rule! (if you know someone who knows
what there doing...)

Good luck.

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

All times are GMT +2. The time now is 03:30.